If a Supreme Court judge can’t draft a will that delivers his wishes – who can?

by Donna Chisholm / 13 October, 2017
RelatedArticlesModule - Will inheritance

Deborah Chambers, QC. Photo/Simon Young

Despite Sir Robert Chambers' carefully drafted will, his adult son was able to trump his last wishes.

When even the finest legal brains in the country can’t craft a will that ensures their wishes are carried out on death, who can?

That was one of the biggest lessons of a case that had family law experts in a lather last year, when David Chambers, son of Supreme Court judge Sir Robert Chambers, who died in 2013, took his stepmother, relationship property and trust expert Lady Deborah Chambers, QC, to court over his father’s will.

The Chambers’ “mirror” wills made their wishes very clear. His two sons and her two daughters from their previous marriage were each to receive a quarter of the couple’s estate to a maximum of $2.5 million. The surviving spouse had the discretion to pay the money at any time after the first anniversary of the other’s death – for example, if the children needed help.

Three of the children accepted the terms of the wills, but David, a Silicon Valley-based software engineer in his early thirties, did not. He did not want to wait, potentially for decades, until his stepmother’s death to receive his share. He wanted it now – despite the fact he was earning US$120,000 a year and was in no financial need.

Although the High Court rejected much of his claim, it ruled that Deborah Chambers was a “constructive trustee” for her stepson and had an obligation to act in his best interests, regardless of whether he was in financial need.

Robert with son David. Photo/Chambers family collection

Having to pay David was an exercise in dead-rat swallowing for his stepmother, and she rails against the wrong-headedness of a law that allows the rights of a financially independent adult child to trump those of a widow or widower – and the express wishes of the deceased.

“When you’re alive, you can give your money whenever you like, to whichever children or charity you like, and no one can stop you. The moment you’re dead, they [the court] can take control over it. There’s something wrong with that concept. What we did was the best that could possibly be achieved under the current law, given that the current law simply fails to tackle the issues of blended families. We did what we thought was incredibly fair for all four of our children and for each other.

“You get angry,” she says of the litigation, which went on for three years. “It really interferes with your grieving. There you are, on your knees, having just lost the great love of your life and then boof, three months later, you get a lawyer’s letter. It was awful. Awful.”

Awful – and unexpected. As masters of the law, the couple thought they’d allowed for every eventuality. The surviving spouse agreed to give the other’s children priority in any payout – meaning their biological children would lose out before the stepchildren. “In effect, it would be only if I was homeless and in the gutter that the children would get nothing. There was never any question that I would not comply with the agreement.”

They also covered off what would happen if either of them remarried, with a contractual obligation to preserve the children’s entitlements in any new partnership. The survivor could not gift property to a trust or their children without paying the same amount to the survivor’s children.

They intended the provision allowing an earlier payout would take effect only if any of the children’s circumstances changed and they needed help. “If David had needed money or been in financial strife for whatever reason, that is exactly what I would have done. As it was, he had a very large sum of money in a bank account, a large share portfolio and was in a well-paid job with no dependants.”

Lady Deborah with her husband Sir Robert Chambers. Photo/Chambers family collection

Assets frozen

After publicity about the court case, she says she was inundated with letters and cards from strangers “who told terrible tales of the destruction of families that was never healed” following FPA litigation.

“There were countless examples of widowed men and women having their assets frozen, meaning they couldn’t access any capital at all. People were borrowing money from friends to survive. There were also tales of appalling litigation costs, which forced people to settle claims, particularly where there were modest estates.”

So, how might a legal challenge from one of the children have been prevented? One way would have been to put their estates into two separate family trusts, with the children of each partner being the ultimate beneficiaries of their own parent’s estate held in the trust.

Another way would have been to write in a clause specifically preventing an earlier payout, but, she says, “that seems wrong” because if the children got into trouble, they’d want to help out.

Trusts can be “busted” in relationship property claims if they’ve been established to defeat the Property (Relationships) Act, but can’t be touched by FPA claims.

However, Deborah Chambers says she and her husband were philosophically opposed to trusts being used to avoid FPA obligations, and the children would have been beneficiaries of any trust, giving them significant rights under existing law. She says given that the children were treated equally and very generously, it never occurred to them that there would be a moral-duty claim.

It’s only natural that beneficiaries would prefer to have the money right away, she says – “who wouldn’t, whether you’re 18 or 65” – but they had to respect the will-maker’s wishes.

“David chose money over family; he chose money over love.”

This article was first published in the August 19, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

Barnaby Joyce hits back over new sexual harassment claim
87494 2018-02-23 06:36:55Z World

Barnaby Joyce hits back over new sexual harassment…

by Michelle Grattan

Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce is under intense new pressure following a new claim of sexual harassment he says is “spurious” and “defamatory”.

Read more
Barack Obama's New Zealand visit could rile Trump supporters
87491 2018-02-23 06:25:22Z Politics

Barack Obama's New Zealand visit could rile Trump …

by Patrick O'Meara

Negotiations to get former US president Barack Obama to visit New Zealand next month are understood to be close to completion.

Read more
Lady Bird – movie review
87403 2018-02-23 00:00:00Z Movies

Lady Bird – movie review

by James Robins

Delicate, poignant honesty marks out Lady Bird from other teenage tales.

Read more
The Royal NZ Ballet transforms The Piano for the stage
86323 2018-02-23 00:00:00Z Theatre

The Royal NZ Ballet transforms The Piano for the s…

by Sharon Stephenson

A masterpiece from New Zealand’s “cinema of unease” is making its world premiere as a full-length ballet.

Read more
What to do in Auckland on a rainy day
87484 2018-02-23 00:00:00Z Where to go in Auckland

What to do in Auckland on a rainy day

by Vomle Springford

When the weather's a bit grim, here are ten ideas for what to do in Auckland.

Read more
Not all over-30s will be as lucky as Jacinda Ardern when it comes to babies
87367 2018-02-23 00:00:00Z Health

Not all over-30s will be as lucky as Jacinda Arder…

by Nicky Pellegrino

After age 30, conceiving naturally becomes more and more of a lottery.

Read more
School shootings rarely happen in NZ – but we’ve got nothing to be smug about
87446 2018-02-22 09:48:43Z Social issues

School shootings rarely happen in NZ – but we’ve g…

by The Listener

New Zealand might not have school shootings; what we do have is a shameful record on child abuse, murder, depression and anxiety.

Read more
Queenstown Council wants luxury homes exempt from sale ban
87443 2018-02-22 09:48:21Z Property

Queenstown Council wants luxury homes exempt from …

by Mei Heron

The council says some expensive homes in the district won't sell because locals won't be able to afford them.

Read more