Our information should be free – why is the OIA an obstacle?

by The Listener / 07 December, 2017
RelatedArticlesModule - OIA information ombudsman

Photo/Getty Images

Chief Ombudsman Peter Boshier has been blunt: the advice that ministers receive from their officials has been deliberately dumbed down, as a consequence of the Official Information Act (OIA).

This was certainly not where we expected to get to when Sir Jim McLay laid this cornerstone of our democratic system in 1982. Its vital contribution to our freedom and governmental accountability has, over successive administrations, been undermined by fear. Subtle and even blatant political heavying from ministers and officials’ self-protective desire not to cause trouble have led state agencies to increasingly refrain from offering potentially contentious advice, because they know it will become public and embarrass them and/or their minister. Another growing trend has been deliberately to delay compliance with an OIA request, or flat out deny it.

Boshier has reversed the latter trend in his two years in the role, partly by making it clear he will name and shame those who fail to co-operate in good faith with the OIA’s processes. But he’s right to say we need new leadership to restore the Act to full efficacy and public respect. In his briefing to the incoming Government, he has usefully clarified the law as it stands, and as he believes officials should adhere to it. The headline clarification is a presumption that all official information will be released, and released in a timely manner, unless there are special reasons not to. A further one is that officials asked to release something under the OIA must not then ask their ministers whether they may do so. It is their obligation to release it unless exempted, and they are only duty-bound to tell ministers to avoid surprises.

A needlessly grey area has developed where officials infer that apprehension on the part of politicians or their advisers obliges them to delay or withhold. KiwiRail changed its plans to release a report before the election merely because it got the impression from ministerial staff that its release would cause political anxiety. Boshier says ministers and their staff have no right to delay or influence OIA responses. Timeliness is a vital element of the Act’s efficacy, however – and that includes the risk of releasing some information too early.

Boshier makes the compelling point that important creative thinking early in policy discussions is being hampered by fear of out-of-context disclosure. The risk of the media highlighting spicy aspects of early discussions has discouraged the valuable tradition of advice “without fear or favour”. Helen Clark’s Government suffered unfairly when 2008 reports highlighted an official’s recommendation to regulate the size of holes in showerheads. This didn’t make it past the first cull of policymaking, but dogged the Government as an emblem of “nanny state-ism”.

Boshier’s solution is to favour release of information only once proposals have reached the stage where serious work is being done – but crucially, before the time has passed when the public can participate in the process. He wants to avoid “every single provocative comment … floated at the beginning” being released at that time, because he says that has contributed to the dumbing down of advice out of fear. But once the decision-making process is advanced, there are few reasons not to release all the advice – and any wacky or draconian early proposals can be seen in their proper context.

Another welcome clarification is that deliberately withholding information until the final OIA deadline, when one could release the information sooner, is not just bad-faith gamesmanship, but also a breach of the law. We can expect the Ombudsman’s office publicly to call out wilful heel-dragging from now on.

Boshier recently wrote to Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern in relation to a 33-page coalition document that she has refused to release, even though Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters describes it as containing “directives to ministers”. Boshier is on the record as noting a culture of transparent Government has to start with strong leadership.

Some have called for the Ombudsman’s office to have stronger powers of coercion, including making serious non-compliance an imprisonable offence. But a better buttress to information freedom would be to automate Boshier’s newly elucidated presumption that all information can be released unless it would cause a serious mischief. Why not a system where, by default, all background papers to a governmental decision are released automatically? This could perhaps happen after early consultations, but before legislative proposals are finalised. Rather than relying on people to request information, why not put the onus on a department or minister to seek, via the Ombudsman, permission not to release it?

It is, after all, our information.

This editorial was first published in the December 16, 2017 issue of the New Zealand Listener.

MostReadArticlesCollectionWidget - Most Read - Used in articles
AdvertModule - Advert - M-Rec / Halfpage

Latest

Barnaby Joyce hits back over new sexual harassment claim
87494 2018-02-23 06:36:55Z World

Barnaby Joyce hits back over new sexual harassment…

by Michelle Grattan

Nationals leader Barnaby Joyce is under intense new pressure following a new claim of sexual harassment he says is “spurious” and “defamatory”.

Read more
Barack Obama's New Zealand visit could rile Trump supporters
87491 2018-02-23 06:25:22Z Politics

Barack Obama's New Zealand visit could rile Trump …

by Patrick O'Meara

Negotiations to get former US president Barack Obama to visit New Zealand next month are understood to be close to completion.

Read more
Lady Bird – movie review
87403 2018-02-23 00:00:00Z Movies

Lady Bird – movie review

by James Robins

Delicate, poignant honesty marks out Lady Bird from other teenage tales.

Read more
The Royal NZ Ballet transforms The Piano for the stage
86323 2018-02-23 00:00:00Z Theatre

The Royal NZ Ballet transforms The Piano for the s…

by Sharon Stephenson

A masterpiece from New Zealand’s “cinema of unease” is making its world premiere as a full-length ballet.

Read more
What to do in Auckland on a rainy day
87484 2018-02-23 00:00:00Z Where to go in Auckland

What to do in Auckland on a rainy day

by Vomle Springford

When the weather's a bit grim, here are ten ideas for what to do in Auckland.

Read more
Not all over-30s will be as lucky as Jacinda Ardern when it comes to babies
87367 2018-02-23 00:00:00Z Health

Not all over-30s will be as lucky as Jacinda Arder…

by Nicky Pellegrino

After age 30, conceiving naturally becomes more and more of a lottery.

Read more
School shootings rarely happen in NZ – but we’ve got nothing to be smug about
87446 2018-02-22 09:48:43Z Social issues

School shootings rarely happen in NZ – but we’ve g…

by The Listener

New Zealand might not have school shootings; what we do have is a shameful record on child abuse, murder, depression and anxiety.

Read more
Queenstown Council wants luxury homes exempt from sale ban
87443 2018-02-22 09:48:21Z Property

Queenstown Council wants luxury homes exempt from …

by Mei Heron

The council says some expensive homes in the district won't sell because locals won't be able to afford them.

Read more